How the story of Chol Soo Lee, who united Asian Americans in fight for justice, was forgotten

Posted on : 2023-10-19 16:51 KST Modified on : 2023-10-19 16:51 KST
The documentary “Free Chol Soo Lee” by Julie Ha and Eugene Yi opened in Korean theaters on Oct. 18
Chol Soo Lee, seen center, is released after being found not guilty of murder. (courtesy of Connect Pictures)
Chol Soo Lee, seen center, is released after being found not guilty of murder. (courtesy of Connect Pictures)

“I was not an angel on the outside. At the same time, I was not the devil.”

So said Chol Soo Lee, who was arrested as a suspect in the 1973 murder of a Chinese man in San Francisco, US. He steadfastly maintained his innocence but was nonetheless sentenced to life in prison. After 10 years behind bars, Lee was exonerated and set free thanks to a solidarity movement led by the Korean diaspora in the area.

His release was the product of the “Free Chol Soo Lee movement” that swept the US in the 1980s, spreading not only among Koreans but across all Asian communities in America.

But this milestone in Korean American history was quickly forgotten. The documentary “Free Chol Soo Lee,” which premiered in Korea on Wednesday, shows why the memory of the event faded so rapidly.

Co-directors Julie Ha and Eugene Yi, both second-generation Korean Americans, said they were puzzled by the fact that they never learned about the incident in school, and only found out about the story as adults.

“In American society, the stories of Asian immigrants are not seen as something that should be written down, so we weren’t exposed to such stories in our schoolbooks or curriculum,” said Yi, who visited South Korea last month. “We decided to make the movie with the intention of leaving this story to the next generation.”

Among those working to free Chol Soo Lee, Ranko Yamada, seen center, was inspired to become a lawyer by his case. (courtesy of Connect Pictures)
Among those working to free Chol Soo Lee, Ranko Yamada, seen center, was inspired to become a lawyer by his case. (courtesy of Connect Pictures)

Neither being film majors, the two directors decided to make their first feature documentary after seeing former reporter Kyung Won Lee (K.W. Lee) weep at Lee’s funeral in 2014.

K.W. Lee is a US-based journalist who made a crucial contribution to the campaign to save Chol Soo Lee. The events in the movie take place in the streets of San Francisco in June 1973, where Chinese gangs were running rampant. There, a gunfight took place, leaving one man dead.

Five days later, Chol Soo Lee was arrested. The bullet found at the scene was the same kind used in a firearm that Chol Soo Lee had, out of curiosity, borrowed from his friend.

Eyewitness testimonies from three white tourists, who only saw the scene from a distance, were used as the basis for identifying and prosecuting Chol Soo Lee.

As an uneducated and unemployed individual without family support, no one listened to his pleas of innocence.

Years later, K.W. Lee, the only journalist with Korean roots in San Francisco at the time, began to investigate the case. His Japanese friend, Ranko Yamada, became a lawyer in order to save Lee from death row.

The late lawmaker Yoo Jae-kun, who was practicing law in the US at the time, played a major role in mobilizing the Korean American community, and middle-aged housewives even donned hanbok as they took part in protests rallying for justice. Finally, in 1982, Lee became a free man.

But this is only half the story. The second half of the film highlights another tragedy that befell Lee after his release. In the early days of his release, he became a symbol of freedom and was invited to various events, where he heard many sympathetic words and much encouragement, but when the spotlight faded and he was unable to adjust to his regular life.

The line-up for the murder of a Chinese gang member included Chol Soo Lee, seen second from right, who was sentenced to life in prison despite pleading his innocence. (courtesy of Connect Pictures)
The line-up for the murder of a Chinese gang member included Chol Soo Lee, seen second from right, who was sentenced to life in prison despite pleading his innocence. (courtesy of Connect Pictures)

The film asks why this happened, unraveling the complex layers of Lee’s life one by one. Lee’s life was an amalgam of trauma from many sources, such as the Korean War, child abuse, maladjustment and racism.

“Free Chol Soo Lee” eschews narratives of triumphalism or individual heroism and instead takes a reflective stance on the darker parts of the story, giving the film cinematic depth.

“There are still many ‘Chol Soo Lees’ out there, shunned by society, such as single mothers, adoptees, North Korean refugees, and prisoners,” said Ha. “I hope the movie will make us think about what we can do for the underprivileged, like the power of the people who tried to save just one human being.”

One person who has been waiting for this movie more than anyone else is K.W. Lee, who played perhaps the most important role in saving Lee’s life, continued to support him as he couldn’t find his footing after his release, and was most heartbroken that his story was forgotten.

He was the first Korean American to break into the US mainstream media, won numerous awards for his reporting, and was named one of the 500 greatest journalists of the 20th century.

“More than 40 years ago, some of the most beautiful people to walk this earth worked together to demonstrate the principle that the humblest among us are equal to kings, queens and presidents,” says K.W. Lee, now 95, recalling the movement to free Chol Soo Lee.

K.W. Lee went further to send a message to South Korea, saying, “This is a lesson we urgently need to hear today.”

By Kim Eun-hyoung, senior staff writer

Please direct questions or comments to [english@hani.co.kr]

button that move to original korean article (클릭시 원문으로 이동하는 버튼)

Related stories

Most viewed articles